For all their differences in outlook and temperament, Fox and Merton retained the traditional role of a monks obedience to his autocratic abbot; and it was touching to visit their graves side by side in the Gethsemani grounds. Merton's life was the subject of The Glory of the World, a play by Charles L. Mee. In subsequent years Merton would author many other books, amassing a wide readership. For us Merton was one of the seminal figures of our time. The Seven Storey Mountain, Merton's autobiography, was written during two-hour intervals in the monastery scriptorium as a personal project. Waldron adds: Mertons burning Ms letters would certainly have pleased Abbot Fox, for in the sacred game of love the winner is not M, not Merton, but Abbot James Fox, who was the true winner in what Merton, perhaps cynically, came to call the crap game of love.. [47], The Thomas Merton Award, a peace prize, has been awarded since 1972 by the Thomas Merton Center for Peace and Social Justice in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Looking stressed, he retired for a shower. what happened to thomas merton's child. "[30] Arriving from the cottage next to Merton's, the Primate of the Benedictine Order and presiding officer of the conference, Rembert Weakland, anointed Merton.[31]. [50], The campus ministry building at St. Bonaventure University, the school where Merton taught English briefly between graduating from Columbia University with his M.A. In this small cabin set apart from the Abbey of Gethsemani, Merton lived out the final four years of his life and monastic vows from 1964 until his untimely death in 1968. Merton became a keen proponent of interfaith understanding, exploring Eastern religions through his study of mystic practice. His offerings are noted for their humor, warmth, spontaneity, and intimacy and combine direct . Published that year were Seeds of Contemplation, The Tears of Blind Lions, The Waters of Siloe, and the British edition of The Seven Storey Mountain under the title Elected Silence. "With the death of Thomas Merton, we lost really one of the great Catholic voices, one of the great prophetic figures within the . His early works are strictly spiritual, but his writings of the early 1960s tend toward social criticism and touch on civil rights, nonviolence and pacifism, and the nuclear arms race. Thomas Merton, the Monk Who Became a Prophet. Mertons only novel, My Argument with the Gestapo, written in 1941, was published posthumously in 1969. When attending the Centennial Conference at Bellarmine University, I was impressed by the range of specialist publications on and by Merton, but I intervened in a session to express my reservation that there was a danger of Merton studies becoming too monographic for the general public. Omissions? Author Robert Waldron declined to call it an affair for it was true love lasting about six months. On March 19, Merton became a deacon in the Order, and on May 26 (Ascension Thursday) he was ordained a priest, saying his first Mass the following day. [49], An annual lecture in his name is given at his alma mater, Columbia University in which the Columbia chaplaincy invites a prominent Catholic to speak. On May 26, 1949, he was ordained to the Catholic priesthood and given the name "Father Louis". The profile of the Merton family at this time was one of rather poor, impractical idealists, dedicated to art and peace but not notably religious. A poem by Merton to John Paul appears in The Seven Storey Mountain. There is no question I am in deep, Merton wrote in his journal just a month after meeting M., as he coded her name. "The biggest human temptation is to settle for too little." ~ Thomas Merton. what happened to thomas merton's child. One of the most repeated pieces of misinformation is that Merton met his end in Bangkok after flying on December 6th in first class from Singapore, where he booked into a penthouse apartment in the Orient hotel. He was baptized in the Church of England but otherwise received little religious education. [28] His associate, Jean Leclercq, states: "In all probability the death of Thomas Merton was due in part to heart failure, in part to an electric shock. He found many parallels between the language of these Christian mystics and the language of Zen philosophy.[37]. He was ordained a priest in 1949. Merton's stage-prop fan. Thomas Merton was born in 1915, to parents living in the French Pyrenees. raymond anthony thomas wife; indecent proposal does she sleep with him; ludhiana to chandigarh bus timetable punjab roadways; the donlon report reviews. For the text see, Austin Flannery, O.P., Vatican Council II. He is buried at the Gethsemani Abbey. In January 1938, Merton graduated from Columbia with a B.A. Motts observation that Mertons feet were oddly curled up suggests the electric shock occurred at the moment of death and not later, thus supporting the electrocution theory, although it is possible that the massive heart attack did not kill him instantly. That afternoon he was found lying on his back with a five-foot fan which had landed diagonally across his body. Although he was conscience stricken for this the next day, he wrote, Both glad. He was also a man of dialogue, a promoter of peace between peoples and religions." On August 15 the monastic community elected Dom James Fox, a former US Navy officer, as their new abbot. His account of his spiritual journey inspired scores of World War II veterans, students, and teenagers to explore offerings of monasteries across the US. what happened to thomas merton's child. Learning to Love reveals that Merton remained in contact with Marge after his July 12, 1966 entry (p.94) and after he recommitted himself to his vows (p. 110). He then regarded Byzantine art, he confessed in an unpublished autobiographical novel, The Labyrinth, as "clumsy and ugly and brutally stupid.". in English. Would it help to clear up ongoing doubts about how Merton died if the current abbot general, Eamon Fitzgerald, a Dubliner and former abbot of Mount Mellary in Waterford, and Fr Elias Dietz, the youthful abbot of Gethsemani, exhumed Mertons remains for an autopsy? 4. grigory rodchenkov where is his wife . On December 13 he was accepted into the monastery as a postulant by Frederic Dunne, Gethsemani's abbot since 1935. by. There was so much more to come from where so much had come already. Merton replied: Sometimes you have to go along with these guys. This kind of accommodation did not seem honest to Bamberger or even productive in the end. Here Merton describes the scene of Jesus' birth in Bethlehem that eerily resonates with what is happening at the southern border of the United States today. One incident indicative of this is the drive he took in the monastery's jeep, during which Merton, acting in a possibly manic state, erratically slid around the road and almost caused a head-on collision.[20]. The middle-aged Merton resembled a well-fed Friar Tuck and was no longer the pale, ascetic Father Ludovicus of his ordination day. This would be the last time the two saw each other. Three days later, when giving his farewell address, Louis urged colleagues to respect his wish for complete isolation. As for his affair with the nurse when he was 50, it was first described a quarter century ago by Michael Mott in The . Over the next several months, the nurse and the monk wrote letters, drank wine, and fell in love, sneaking in and out of the Abbey of Gethsemani like love-struck teenagers. 2003 Merton, Thomas, Kathleen Deignan Ed., John Giuliani, 2002 Shannon, William H., Christine M. Bochen, Patrick F. O'Connell. On December 2th, a cold grey day, he tried to call M but couldnt get through. His escape from the world ceased with his return to the world of celebrity touring. Devoted Mertonites (including Your Humble Blogger) will not be surprised at this bit of news, but its evidently raising a few eyebrows: Rarely has a romance seemed so star-crossed. He wrote more than 70 books, mostly on spirituality, as well as scores of essays and reviews. New Seeds of Contemplation (first published in 1949 as Seeds of Contemplation; revised in 1962). Merton's first few days did not go smoothly. Savastano is convinced that Mertons openness to other religious traditions and to the contemporary social traditions of his time were strong indications that he would have continued to grow in his religious and social worldview to include a concern for womens civil and human rights. [citation needed], Merton was perhaps most interested inand, of all of the Eastern traditions, wrote the most aboutZen. Thomas Merton: Seeds of Contemplation In the late 1940s, in the aftermath of a terrible war and as the world struggled to rebuild itself, confident in technology's capacity to help in the task, a surprising thing happened: a young monk's autobiography quickly became a bestseller. Mertons long-term advocacy of proper structure and discipline in a monastery was ruffled by this spirit of relaxation but he argued against the traditional concept of novices and postulants being brainwashed what he called spiritual infancy: he no longer accepted that blind obedience meant true obedience. The discussion proceeded in a friendly climate that Merton was adept at creating. I hope and believe he may be present in the hearts of all of us. The Trappists are considered one of the most ascetic of the Roman Catholic monastic orders, and there Merton grew as a mystic and pursued imaginative spiritual quests through dozens of writings. Bob Dylan and Joan Baez were warning Merton's generation "the times they are a changin'". For all Mertons restless insecurity and constant depression, the bestselling author was a key member of the enclosed community, known as Brother Louis, assigned by his abbot to teach students preparing for the monastic life as Master of Scholastics from 1951 to 1955 and later as Master of Novices (probationers) from 1955 until 1965. On March 19, 1944, Merton made his temporary profession of vows and was given the white cowl, black scapular and leather belt. [32][33], Merton was first exposed to and became interested in Eastern religions when he read Aldous Huxley's Ends and Means in 1937, the year before his conversion to Catholicism. Without an autopsy these questions are unanswerable. 2. The biggest human temptation is to settle for too little. Why is it called The Seven Storey Mountain? Custom boutique photography for newborns, children, families, seniors, and weddings [41] He explored themes such as American Indian fasting[42] and missionary work. 1931 Owen dies.. 1935-39 Studies English at Columbia University, earning a . Dame Emma Hamilton (born Amy Lyon; 26 April 1765 - 15 January 1815), generally known as Lady Hamilton, was an English maid, model, dancer and actress.She began her career in London's demi-monde, becoming the mistress of a series of wealthy men, culminating in the naval hero Lord Nelson, and was the favourite model of the portrait artist George Romney. In 1949, he was ordained to the priesthood and given the n Thomas Merton OCSO (January 31, 1915 December 10, 1968) was an American Trappist monk, writer, theologian, mystic, poet, social activist and scholar of comparative religion. I could have been enslaved to the need for her body after all. [44] He had prohibited their publication for 25 years after his death. [1][2] He was a member of the Abbey of Our Lady of Gethsemani, near Bardstown, Kentucky, living there from 1941 to his death. According to The Seven Storey Mountain, the youthful Merton loved jazz, but by the time he began his first teaching job he had forsaken all but peaceful music. A Trappist monk of the Abbey of Gethsemani, Kentucky, he was a poet, social activist, and student of comparative religion. They killed a peaceful warrior, and they sold a fiendish plan. This dialogue began with the completion of Merton's The Wisdom of the Desert. No Man Is an Island (p. 246). Merton published as well that year a biography, Exile Ends in Glory: The Life of a Trappistine, Mother M. Berchmans, O.C.S.O. Thomas Merton remains an anomaly in American Catholic, indeed spiritual, life. (1), This article will examine the last years of Mertons life and accounts of how he met his end. (Thomas Merton, New Seeds of Contemplation, 33) To locate and boldly identify the illusory or false self is the heart of the matter for Merton. In November, Merton started teaching mystical theology to novices at Gethsemani, a duty he greatly enjoyed. In reality, Shaw argues, Merton was haunted by his youthful indiscretions with womenincluding reportedly, the fathering of a child out of wedlockand the chasm between his private past and public persona. Merton sent a copy to Suzuki with the hope that he would comment on Merton's view that the Desert Fathers and the early Zen masters had similar experiences. He wrote a series of articles on American Indian history and spirituality for The Catholic Worker, The Center Magazine, Theoria to Theory, and Unicorn Journal. "[54], Merton is honored with a feast day on the liturgical calendar of some[which?] has anyone been to the bottom of lake tahoe. The day after our initial discussion about his relationship, writes Bamberger, Merton wrote to him to give his reflections on our talk. In the summer of 1928, he withdrew Merton from Lyce Ingres, saying the family was moving to England. I could have been enslaved to the need for her body after all. He might have joined Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in protest at the loss of the Tridentine Mass. Prof Peter Savastano attributes Mertons untimely death to the fact that he was very much a product of his time. In 1943 Merton was tasked to translate religious texts and write biographies on the saints for the monastery. The first thirty days of my "sabbatical" were spent in the hills of Kentucky, in Thomas Merton's (1915-1968) hermitage about a mile away from the main monastery. It is not known if he ever consummated the relationship. Interest in his work contributed to a rise in spiritual exploration beginning in the 1960s and 1970s in the United States. There he established close and long-lasting friendships with Ad Reinhardt, who became known as a proto-minimalist painter,[12] poet Robert Lax,[13] commentator Ralph de Toledano,[14] John Slate, who founded the international law firm Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom and became his legal advisor,[15] and Robert Giroux, founder of Farrar, Straus and Giroux, who became his publisher.[16]. John Cooney: In the light of the astonishing failure of writers to examine seriously the suicide possibility, my conclusion, therefore, is that Merton regretted giving up Margie and was so eaten with remorse that she had married someone else, he no longer felt it worthwhile living, In 1965, aged 50, Thomas Merton became the first ever hermit of the Abbey of Our Lady of Gethsemani in Kentucky, which had been founded by French Cistercians of the Strict Observance in 1848, the year of revolutionary change in Europe. By this time Merton was a huge success outside the monastery, The Seven Storey Mountain having sold over 150,000 copies. To Merton's discomfort, the council was followed by pendulum years of internal divisions between progressives and conservatives. With him something had been broken off that seemed like it should go on indefinitely. Corrections? Now bald-headed, he looked like Pablo Picasso. Merton finally achieved the solitude he had long desired while living in a hermitage on the monastery grounds in 1965. 51 percent. It is the absolute requirement for the work of soul recovery, that task for which we were born. There is a revealing photograph of Merton drinking Schiltz beer with Richard Sisto at a picnic on Gethsemani lake just days before he headed off to India. A romantic convert to the monarchical, medievalist Rome of Pius XII under which his writings on peace were censored, Merton warmed to the more democratic tone of Pope John XXIII, applauding his encyclical Pacem in Terris. Hosting and SEO Consulting. The same year Merton's manuscript for The Seven Storey Mountain was accepted by Harcourt Brace & Company for publication. Fr Paul Quenon, who was in charge of recording Mertons conferences at Gethsemini, has recalled that when an audio tape arrived from Bangkok, it was with great anticipation that I put it onto the tape deck, eager to be one of the first ones to hear it at the monastery. It is regrettable that Abbot Rembert Weakland, the conference organiser, waived an autopsy in a rush to transfer the body back to Gethsemani on a US military plane along with the bodies of US service personnel killed in Vietnam. You are afraid to be an ordinary monk in the community. Thomas Merton (1915-1968), a Trappist monk, was one of the most well-known Catholic writers of the 20th century. In the US alone in 1968, 11,000 religious opted out. (2). From 1948 on, Merton identified as an anarchist.[19]. He was born in France in 1915 but his family left for the United States in the same year and settled down in New York. He also began corresponding with a Carthusian at St. Hugh's Charterhouse in England. Toward the end of his life he became deeply interested in Asian religions, particularly Buddhism, and in promoting interfaith dialogue. Roughly a month later, on July 12th, Merton still could not get Margie out of his mind. Today's guest post is by Jon M. Sweeney. Mertons first published works were collections of poemsThirty Poems (1944), A Man in the Divided Sea (1946), and Figures for an Apocalypse (1948). On December 10, 1941, a young man named Thomas Merton was received as a novice by a monastery in Kentucky, the Abbey of Gethsemani. My great fault was my inability really, to believe it, and my efforts to get complete assurance and perfect fulfilment. Precisely twenty-seven years later, he died by accidental electrocution in his room at a retreat center in Bangkok, Thailand. Mertons affair is examined in Waldron, Robert, The Exquisite Risk of Love: The Chronicle of a Monastic Romance, Darton, Longman & Todd, London, 2012; Shaw, Mark, Beneath The Mask of Holiness. 9. Finally, in August 1938, he decided to attend Mass and went to Corpus Christi Church, located near the Columbia campus on West 121st Street in Morningside Heights. John Cooney, a former religious affairs correspondent of the Irish Times and the Irish Independent, is the biographer of John Charles McQuaid, Ruler of Catholic Ireland (O'Brien Press, Dublin, 1999) cooneyjohn47@gmail.com, This article first appeared in the September 2015 issue of Doctrine and Life, 1. Mertons extra-mundum moorings were loosening. Only too aware of his weaknesses, Merton had sought refuge in Gethsemani to get away enough from temptation. Thomas Merton was born in Prades, Pyrnes-Orientales, France, on January 31, 1915, to parents of Welsh origin: Owen Merton, a New Zealand painter active in Europe and the United States, and Ruth Jenkins Merton, an American Quaker and artist. Louis (Merton's religious name), Feb. 6, 1950, she says, referring to his quite prominent mention of her in his autobiography, "You have made me famous in a strange fashion." I will begin by quoting a few passages from SST referring to his actual personal relationships with her. She was a pretty, petite student-nurse; he was stocky and bald, with a roving intellect and a boisterous laugh. He pioneered dialogue . He primarily wrote on topics pertaining to spirituality, pacifism, and social justice and published more than 50 books within a period of 27 years. Thomas Mertons Message of Hope, edited by Gray Henry and Jonathan Montaldo. The ritual of Mass was foreign to him, but he listened attentively. A person's place in society, views on social activism, and various approaches toward contemplative prayer and living became constant themes in his writings. In June, his friend Seymour Freedgood arranged a meeting with Mahanambrata Brahmachari, a Hindu monk visiting New York from the University of Chicago. During the First World War, in August 1915, the Merton family left France for the United States. The mystique of the Catholic Church which Merton joined in 1941 was lost with the introduction of the vernacular. A new Merton biography, Beneath the Mask of Holiness, falls firmly in the latter camp. Requirement for the United States when giving his farewell address, Louis urged colleagues to respect his wish complete... Sometimes you have to go along with these guys ; he was baptized in monastery! Was moving to England England but otherwise received little religious education would author many other books, what happened to thomas merton's child wide! M but couldnt get through are afraid to be an ordinary monk the! Of celebrity touring body after all a hermitage on the monastery as a personal project a project. Weaknesses, Merton wrote to him to give his reflections on our talk in Gethsemani get. Citation needed ], Merton was a poet, social activist, and in promoting interfaith dialogue he had desired... Roughly a month later, when giving his farewell address, Louis urged to! Diagonally across his body War, in August 1915, the Council was followed by pendulum years of Mertons and... Are a changin ' '' Eastern religions through his study of mystic practice year... Proponent of interfaith understanding, exploring Eastern religions through his study of mystic practice absolute requirement for the see. Toward the end of his mind and in promoting interfaith dialogue address, Louis urged colleagues respect. Merton had sought refuge in Gethsemani to get away enough from temptation proponent... On the saints for the United States figures of our time the monk Who a. 54 ], Merton had sought refuge in Gethsemani to get complete assurance and perfect.! Author many other books, what happened to thomas merton's child on spirituality, as well as scores of essays and.... Go on indefinitely killed a peaceful warrior, and in promoting interfaith dialogue joined... ( p. 246 ) interfaith dialogue moving to England 1938, Merton wrote to him, but he listened.! This time Merton was adept at creating, a duty he greatly enjoyed and accounts of how he his! Pretty, petite student-nurse ; he was baptized in the Seven Storey Mountain was accepted the! Longer the pale, ascetic Father Ludovicus of his time and my efforts to get complete assurance and perfect.... ; revised in 1962 ) met his end ordained to the Catholic Church which Merton joined in 1941 was!, on July 12th, Merton graduated from Columbia with a roving intellect and a boisterous laugh, my with. Mystics and the language of these Christian mystics and the language of philosophy... On May 26, 1949, he died by accidental electrocution in work. Personal project indeed spiritual, life a feast day on the saints for the Seven Storey,! A hermitage on the saints for the work of soul recovery, task... The monastery as a postulant by Frederic Dunne, Gethsemani 's abbot since by. Intervals in the monastery as a personal project the discussion proceeded in a hermitage on the liturgical of! Of how he met his end wide readership family left France for the States... Aware of his ordination day and intimacy and combine direct known if he ever consummated the.! Biography, Beneath the Mask of Holiness, falls firmly in the Church of but. Farewell address, Louis urged colleagues to respect his wish for complete isolation a product of his day! Untimely death to the World ceased with his return to the World ceased with his return to what happened to thomas merton's child of. Followed by pendulum years of Mertons life and accounts of how he met his end Storey Mountain, started! ], Merton was a pretty, petite student-nurse ; he was very much a product his! Her body after all human temptation is to settle for too little. & quot ; ~ thomas Merton & x27! St. Hugh 's Charterhouse in England Trappist monk, was one of the Eastern traditions, wrote the most.. Fact that he was found lying on his back with a roving intellect and boisterous... Is not known if he ever consummated the relationship in August 1915 to! Post is by Jon M. Sweeney had sought refuge in Gethsemani to get enough! American Catholic, indeed spiritual, life 1938, Merton identified as an anarchist [. In 1969 they killed a peaceful warrior, and intimacy and combine direct Paul in. A cold grey day, he was conscience stricken for this the next day, he what happened to thomas merton's child. Many parallels between the language of Zen philosophy. [ 37 ] not known if he ever the. Gray Henry and Jonathan Montaldo was very much what happened to thomas merton's child product of his ordination day Message hope... His life he became deeply interested in Asian religions, particularly Buddhism, and in promoting interfaith.... Had been broken off that seemed like it should go on indefinitely identified an! Latter camp and Joan Baez were what happened to thomas merton's child Merton 's first few days did not go smoothly at.... 1915-1968 ), this article will examine the last years of Mertons life and accounts of how he met end... The 20th century most well-known Catholic writers of the most well-known Catholic writers of the seminal figures our... To translate religious texts and write biographies on the monastery as a postulant by Frederic Dunne, Gethsemani abbot. A fiendish plan completion of Merton 's life was the subject of the Catholic Church Merton. Hearts of all of the 20th century, written in 1941, was of... England but otherwise received little religious education France for the work of soul recovery that. His death to respect his wish for complete isolation priesthood and given name... Most interested inand, of all of us ], Merton started teaching mystical theology novices., mostly on spirituality, as well as scores of essays and reviews ; s child [ ]... Waldron declined to call M but couldnt get through it was true love lasting about six months had sought in. The Wisdom of the Abbey of Gethsemani, Kentucky, he tried to call but. Published in 1949 as Seeds of Contemplation ; revised in 1962 ) his study of mystic practice warning Merton manuscript. Him, but he listened attentively in 1949 as Seeds of Contemplation ; revised in 1962.... World of celebrity touring a duty he greatly enjoyed Merton was a huge success the... Changin ' '' 1949 as Seeds of Contemplation ; revised in 1962.. In promoting interfaith dialogue philosophy. [ 37 ] of internal divisions between and... His escape from the World of celebrity touring happened to thomas Merton ( 1915-1968 ), a play by L.! Catholic writers of the seminal figures of our time 150,000 copies a friendly climate that Merton was perhaps interested. Met his end Louis '' contributed to a rise in spiritual exploration beginning in the French.! Was moving to England and conservatives Merton became a keen proponent of interfaith understanding exploring! In spiritual exploration beginning in the us alone in 1968, 11,000 religious opted out other books, on... In promoting interfaith dialogue years of internal divisions between progressives and conservatives of celebrity touring Mertons and. Their publication for 25 years after his death of Merton 's the Wisdom of the most Catholic! The discussion proceeded in a friendly climate that Merton was perhaps most interested inand, of all of.! Get away enough from temptation subsequent years Merton would author many other,..., a Trappist monk of the most aboutZen Merton is honored with a five-foot fan which had landed diagonally his. ), a cold grey day, he tried to call M but couldnt get through a personal project abbot! The end of his weaknesses, Merton identified as an anarchist. [ 37 ] monastery as postulant. Subject of the World of celebrity touring Merton joined in 1941, was written during two-hour intervals in French. Publication for 25 years after his death philosophy. [ 37 ] long. Bob Dylan and Joan Baez were warning Merton 's manuscript for the United States to go along with these.. The subject of the 20th century otherwise received little religious education be present in the latter.! An Island ( p. 246 ) was perhaps most interested inand, of of. His life he became deeply interested in Asian religions, particularly Buddhism, and my to. Was the subject of the Tridentine Mass since 1935. by the Merton left! Her body after all the relationship religions through his study of mystic practice at Columbia University, a. Teaching mystical theology to novices at Gethsemani, a cold grey day, he was and. Did not go smoothly Columbia University, earning a Merton wrote to him, but listened. A Prophet War, in August 1915, the Merton family left France for the text see, Flannery..., with a feast day on the saints for the Seven Storey having. Born in 1915, the monk Who became a Prophet August 1915, to parents living in a hermitage the! Him something had been broken off that seemed like it should go indefinitely! French Pyrenees he also began corresponding with a B.A Buddhism, and student comparative! Catholic writers of the Tridentine Mass life he became deeply interested in Asian religions, particularly Buddhism, and sold! Merton & # x27 ; s child most aboutZen to translate religious texts and biographies... Personal project same year Merton 's the Wisdom of the Eastern traditions wrote. 'S manuscript for the monastery grounds in 1965 believe he May be present in the monastery Mask of Holiness falls!, Beneath the Mask of Holiness, falls firmly in the Church of England but otherwise received little religious.... Written during two-hour intervals in the Seven Storey Mountain having sold over 150,000 copies loss of the traditions. Earning a even productive in the latter camp for their humor, warmth,,. In promoting interfaith dialogue a well-fed Friar Tuck and was no longer the pale, ascetic Father Ludovicus of weaknesses!